Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Sensitivity And Responsiveness To Differences

PROMPT #6

In my personal classroom experience, from kindergarten all the way to college, teachers communicate in vastly different ways. Some yell, some mumble, some joke, some are silent even. But the thing that ties them all together is that they use these various ways to communicate with their students. Obviously some are more effective than others, but it's up to the teacher to see what works best. I've only ever had one teacher who yelled, but it was enough of a bad experience to make me realize I'd never be a yeller. There are better ways to communicate, and communication is such a huge part of teaching, and of learning.

Communication is how teachers convey to their students what they need to learn, how they need to learn, and what's expected of them. Mrs. Kandy, the teacher of my classroom, is very thorough with her communication. She explains what the activity is for the time period, and how to do the activity, with several examples. But she goes the extra inch to explain what she doesn't want too. This way, no student is left wondering what's expected of them. And they don't have to fear they're doing the wrong thing, because they know what is considered incorrect.

I also noticed a few tactics Mrs. Kandy has that all her students understand. Without any explanation, she'll begin to count from one to three, and when she reaches three, everyone is silent. It always works. And it amazes me. It's also sort of clever. By giving the students those two seconds before they have to be silent, it allows them to say their final words, then devote their complete attention to Mrs. Kandy when she wants it. Thinking about these various ways of communication, however subtle they are, makes me realize that there are so many different ways to express ideas in a classroom.

I've also seen Mrs. Kandy communicate in a different way. She knows her students so well, and on one day, after everyone got off the rug and went to their desks, she asked Jerry to come speak with her. She'd noticed that he'd been quiet that day, and seemed kind of tired. And after asking him what was wrong, it was revealed that he hadn't gotten much sleep because his dad, who works two jobs, had come home late the night before, exhausted and grumpy, and he'd been upset to find no one had left him and dinner. So, Jerry's parents had fought, and Jerry had been woken up by it. Mrs. Kandy let him talk, and told him he should make sure to get more sleep the next night, and she also said he could take it easy that day in class. While she was talking to him, she had her hand on his shoulder and her voice was very soft. I found this to be very touching to watch, because Jerry seemed better after it. Mrs. Kandy had realized that Jerry needed some special treatment due to home issues, and she'd given it to him. She wouldn't speak that way to every student that day, but that was because no one else seemed to be having problems. But because Jerry had needed some reassurance, she'd changed her communication style to be more sensitive and responsive to her student.

Her various teaching styles remind me of Lisa Delpit. In Delpit's article, she states that "if you are not already a participant in the culture of power, being told explicitly the rules of that culture makes acquiring power easier" (3). Mrs. Kandy is always explicit in her explanations, and she makes sure that everyone in the classroom understands what's going on. She also makes sure the students understand what's not acceptable behavior, and informs her students of what is acceptable, which will ultimately help them when they enter the community as adults.

Delpit also states that every child should not be treated the same way, in relation to their communication styles. Some kids need to be talked to in a gentle manner, and some need strict direction. Mrs. Kandy is an effective teacher because she alters her communication styles to each student and uses different methods to best interact with them.

5 comments:

  1. I thought it was quite amusing on how your teacher can silence an entire classroom by counting to three. But despite this effectiveness in an elementary setting, I am somewhat skeptical that this technique would transfer into a secondary education classroom like we both will be teaching in in our future.
    Another thing that I agree with you on is the policy of never yelling. I think that the best teachers that I have ever had do not get angry at you, if you make a mistake they get disappointed in you. They expect for you to do better and they make it visually apparent through body language that they would like for you to do the right thing in the future. I myself do not appreciate getting yelled at, and admittedly, I will often respond with defiance. So when I am on the other side of the desk, teaching others, I cannot allow myself to be hypocritical. It is important for all teachers to respond to their students channeling respect, because if you respect your students, then your students will in turn, respect you, and if you obtain the respect of your students, it will minimize problems within a classroom.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The teacher in your classroom seems very attuned to working with students from many different backgrounds. I think that the way a teacher manages her classroom is directly proportional to the way that the students respond. Just as Mrs. Kandy did, it's important to outline what is expected of them and also what is not acceptable in the classroom. It leaves the students very little room for questioning. I do, however, agree with Luke's skepticism on the counting technique. It may work for some classrooms but I believe that it is something that may have to be implemented for a substantial amount of time before it catches on based upon the age level or personalities of the class.
    Each child is different and I found it very appropriate that you related your blog to Delpit. Each child is different and need to be treated accordingly. All students have different learning styles and it is important for a teacher to recognize that. The only way to be able to teach a successful class is to cater each one of your lessons to every single student. Although that may be a lot of work for you, as the teacher, If you want to be an effective educator you must do it.It all depends simply on if you want to be a good teacher or a mediocre teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with both Luke and Kaitlyn in that I am skeptical of the teacher's counting technique to quiet the children. Although it may have worked for this particular teacher, I have seen many other techniques that are much more effective. Delpit is the perfect theorist to relate this blog to because all children are different and need special attention. This is crucial for the classroom teacher to recognize this and adjust his or her strategies for these individual learners.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is lame. But i completely agree with everyone who already commented here. I think the counting thing may sometimes work but there are other affective ways that quiet children, but I think this is a great way to do it too.
    I think its amazing how your teacher approached the situation with the little boy. You lucked out in getting such an understanding and attentive teacher who obviously loves her job and her students. I think the teachers who are respected and who make the biggest impact on children are the teachers who pay individual attention all of their students, especially the ones who need it the most. Its great to see teachers that still love doing their job.
    Delpit was the perfect theorist to use in this blog. I like the quotes you used to support your ideas as well. Communication is the key.

    ReplyDelete